3% of Students Understand their Grade; Teachers are Begging for Help

Teachers, students, and parents of Vashon Island School District (VISD), if you have questions about the district's new grade book Qmlativ, you are far from alone. The first quarter of this serchool year has brought up questions faster than even the teachers and staff could find answers. This story is developing, and many questions remain unanswered, but this is, to the best of The Riptide's knowledge, the story of Qmlativ.
The district switched from Skyward to Qmlativ this past summer.
"We had a software called Skyward, and Skyward was updating and becoming Qmlativ. That wasn't a choice that we got to make. That was just a system overhaul. My understanding is that we put that transfer off for as long as we possibly could. There was literally a day that old Skyward was just gonna go away and we were gonna have new software," said Kathleen Regovich, a chemistry teacher at Vashon High School (VHS).
"Ironically, it's a product that's about 10 years old, but it's new to us because they've been slowly transitioning schools," said Dr. Stephanie Spencer, the Director of Curriculum at VISD.
The transition from Skyward to Qmlativ was not presented as a change in grading philosophy. It was only intended as an update to a more modern system. Dr. Spencer maintains that this is still true.
"There was nothing new this year in terms of how the grade books were set up other than we made sure they were uniformly set up," said Dr. Spencer.
However, many teachers and students have found that the grade book behaves quite differently than years prior.
Both the old Skyward and new Qmlativ used something called a trend line to calculate grades. The trend line uses past scores of students to predict what the student's next grade in the category should be. This is called "predictive grading".
"Skyward was really awesome because I think that the trend line was more predictable. I liked the formula they were using behind the scenes. It seemed to work a lot better than this one does. I think that that one would trend your grade down less often than this one does. This one just seems to constantly want to trend you down, especially compared to the previous one, and I think that that is inherently against the concept of the trend line," said Eli Berman, a junior at VHS..
The new formula that Qmlativ uses to calculate grades is called the power law. This is a different formula than Skyward used. The formula, see fig.1, has proven to be quite difficult for students and teachers to understand.

A poll of 120 VHS students asked them to rate how well they understand how their grades are calculated on a scale of one to five, five being a perfect understanding, and one being no understanding. 18.3% of students responded having no understanding of how their grades are calculated, with 82.5% reporting a three or lower. Only 3.3% of the students said they have a perfect understanding of the calculation.
Teachers are aware of this problem, but many feel they are unable to help students understand it as they lack an understanding of it themselves.
"The concern is the way it's calculating things. We have no ability to describe it, and I don't even think that our admin and district people can describe it in a way that makes sense to students and teachers. For example, a student gets a zero on one assignment, a 0.5 on another assignment, and somehow they have a 2.5 in the class. If that could make sense to anyone, I would really love for them to explain that to me," said Zach Beebe, an English teacher at VHS.
"If our gradebook is not communicating to those students on the seventh, eighth week of school, we are doing a disservice to our community, and it needs to be solved immediately. I think there is an easy solution," said Beebe.
Other teachers feel similarly.
"The thing that I know for sure is that basically all of the teachers don't really agree with the trend line. I think if you ask different people, they'll answer different things. I personally don't like it because the thing it does is it tries to be predictive and that makes no sense to me. I don't understand why I would want to predict a student's future grade based on their current performance. I want to know what they have currently been able to accomplish," said Regovich.
Regovich and Beebe are two of many teachers opposing the trend line. On September 15, a letter was sent to Superintendent Dr. Moccia and Dr. Spencer signed by every teacher at VHS without fail. The letter contained a clear request:
"We request that trendline grading be turned off as soon as possible, and replaced with a simple averaging of scores. We believe this change will support the district’s goals of teachers recognizing individual student learning needs, empowering students to own their learning, and students’ working toward competence in core learning standards," wrote the teachers.
The letter continues, "Years of experience show that students are often unable to figure out how their trendlined assessment scores result in a given course grade… What the trendline doesn’t handle well is the case where a student’s performance is uneven and their scores do not continually increase. This makes it difficult to impossible for teachers and students to understand how a particular assignment will impact a student’s grade. And if we and our students struggle to understand how a course grade reflects student learning, it is even harder for families to make sense of grades as a report of how their students are currently doing."
Teachers are very aligned on the problem. They appear to, given the unanimously signed letter, all be facing the same issue, all find it unacceptable, and all agree on the same solution.
"As a teacher, I can easily explain an average in a category. I cannot explain whatever this trendline thing is doing," said Beebe.
However, this proposition has been met with significant pushback at the district level.
"I don't know how many people in the district are saying no, but there seems to be resistance at the district level," said Beebe.
Who exactly is resisting an average is not entirely clear, which has been another source of confusion for teachers. In addition, it is unclear who actually holds the final say on how the gradebook looks. The most specific, reliable answer that The Riptide could find was that, according to Dr. Spencer, "it'll probably ultimately be an administrative decision."
Dr. Spencer, a district-level administrator, has expressed that she is against an average and supports the trend line.
"It's just inconsistent with standards-based grading. A standards-based model is all interested in what our students can know and be able to demonstrate right now, not an average over time of all their scores in one bucket," said Spencer.
She gave an analogy to explain it, "Let's say you go to take your driver's test, right? And you take your written test and you get a 60%. And then the next time you take it, you get an 80%, but oh too bad, you don't get to pass yet because your average is 70."
VISD is a standards based district. That transition began around a decade ago, finishing around 2022. The standards based approach to grading and the philosophy laid out above by Dr. Spencer is the official grading philosophy of the district. However, this year has brought up a plethora of questions regarding how well standards based grading actually works, and how committed to the district actually is.
Dr. Spencer explained that she thought students should be in favor of a trend line.
"I would think that students would want to push back on that [an average] too. Because if you can now demonstrate and know material that maybe at first you struggled with or didn't fully get a three on, then why would you want to settle for an average of your scores? If you're now able to demonstrate that you have at least at a three consistently, why would you want those ones and twos or two and a halves or whatever to impact your overall grade? I would think there would be significant pushback on that," said Dr. Spencer.

However, her opinion does not appear to be popular among students. A poll of the same 120 VHS students showed that nearly 80% of students support an average, while only around 13% prefer the trend line. The remaining ~7% supported various other systems.
The trend line itself is clearly unpopular among students and teachers. Additionally, students and teachers are upset with how the district has been handling the issue.
"It doesn't feel like we're being treated like professionals who know things about you [students]. We are the people who interact with the gradebook the most. We're the ones who interact with students and families with regards to their grades the most," said Regovich.
"I would definitely want to see more clarity. I would really like it if someone in the district was like, we're doing standards-based grading, and we're going to do trendlining, and this is why. Or we're going to do standards-based grading, and we're going to do a decaying average, and this is why. I feel like everyone is waffling so much that it feels like there's no clarity," said Charlie Ralston, a science teacher at McMurray Middle School.
"When teachers are in unison saying these things then I think there just needs to be an open ear to that and to say okay how can we make this work, and work with us not necessarily against us or give us options that complicate the situation further rather than actually solve the problem," said Beebe.
District administrators are aware of how teachers feel. They did respond to the letter, and have had meetings with some teachers.
"I think what we would be more curious about doing is having conversations with those teachers to make sure they fully understand what we're trying to accomplish with standards-based grading. And I'm not saying that in a derogatory way. It makes me really question if they really truly understand what it is that we hope to achieve with our standards-based grading system,” said Dr. Spencer.

All of this discontent among teachers appears to show a correlation with student sentiment as well. The Riptide poll showed that over 88% of students feel that Qmlativ is worse than Skyward was.
So where do things stand now? On October 20th, the grade book was, without warning, shut down, rendering grades inaccessible to students. Teachers were also given no prior warning – they received the exact same message students did at the exact same time. Teachers were still able to access the grade book.
Dr. Spencer shared that the district made the decision to close down the grade book as a means of mitigating confusion among students as they make changes to it. After the switch to Qmlativ this summer, many pieces of the grade book were not functioning as the district intended, beyond just the trend line. They were unable to get those kinks sorted out before students started using the gradebook. If they made those changes while there were assignments already entered into the grade book, students' grades would likely change without any new assignments being entered. The district administrators reached the conclusion that it would be less confusing for students if they just turned it off while they made the changes. This would make it impossible to distinguish any grade fluctuations they cause from genuine assignments changing the grade.
"The whole idea was let's just close it off, let's work on cleaning up these pieces and then turn it back on," said Dr. Spencer.
In response to the letter, albeit after several weeks had gone by, the district offered teachers an option for what the grade book could look like. If they didn't want the trend line, they could either choose a "decaying average" or "subjective grading". This came with the caveat that all teachers in the district must use the same option. They could not have one teacher use a decaying average and one use subjective grading. They all had to align.
"A decaying average means that the last grade that you put in that standard is going to weigh 65% of your grade. Everything else before that standard is 35%. So I find that kind of weird for our standards because we don't even get final exams at this school. That fits to me more of a final exam kind of idea and we don't even offer that," said Beebe.
"The other option is what they're calling subjective grading. And they're basically saying you can look at how the student has done in that standard and you can adjust what they're scoring in that particular standard to what it reflects them doing. That scares me a little bit because what is going to be the consistency across the school? Are some people just going to kind of eyeball it and go, that looks like a three, right? Is that going to make sense to a student? Is that going to make sense to a parent?" continued Beebe.
"Personally, I am more interested in the decaying average than the subjective grading, just because I think it works well for me as a science teacher," said Ralston.
Since the time of both of those interviews, the district has opted to use subjective grading. That decision came after a poll was sent out to teachers asking their preference. An averaging gradebook was not given as an option.
At the time of this writing, that is more or less how things stand. On November fourth, an email was sent out to VHS students from Principal John Erickson saying that when access to the gradebook is restored, overall grades may not be accurate. He asked that teachers be given two weeks to make sure grades are up to date.
The transition to subjective grading brings up many more questions, which have yet to be answered, and many decisions are still being made by teachers on how they are going to implement the new system. The Riptide will continue to follow this story as it develops.

Comments