top of page

Chivas v. Club America

5 hours ago
3 min read
A Chivas player is stealing the ball from a player from Club America. Students debate on who is the best team photo courtesy of Yahoo! Sports.
A Chivas player is stealing the ball from a player from Club America. Students debate on who is the best team photo courtesy of Yahoo! Sports.

Chivas versus Club America is one of the biggest soccer rivalries in Mexico. Any time they play against each other, everyone is always on their phone checking the score, making sure their favorite team is winning. 

Each team has their own unique history. Chivas was founded in 1906, and after two years, they changed their name to the Guadalajara Football Club. Club America was founded in 1916. Their first ever match against each other was on July 29,1943. The score was 1-0 with Chivas winning the game. Overall, Club America has beaten Chivas by 99 wins, while Chivas has 82 wins against Club America, but over all they  have tied 83 times including official matches and friendlies. Chivas has a rule that their players have to be born in Mexico to represent their team. This shows how much Chivas cares about their country, culture and talent.

“I love the fact that all of their players are Mexican and that they do not get any players that are not Mexican. Even if they're born in a different country they are still Mexican,” said junior Sofia Gomez.

Fans like Sofia don't just care about skills or how many trophies a team has, they care about their identity and pride.

In contrast, Club America is very different. They are very wealthy and don’t care if their players are not from Mexico. They always try to get the best players, but they are one of the most hated clubs in Mexico. It all started in the  80s when Club America was bought from Telivisa.That made them have lots of power. While the other clubs were fighting for success, Club America already had that, so they weren't struggling at all; they had achieved money, good players, professional coaches. Club America is very controversial lots of fans think that because of how many trophies they have and how much more power they have then other clubs.  

“All of my life I have been taught of the Chivas vs Club America rivalry even if America is statistically the better team, I think that Chivas is better because of their history and the deep meaning behind the club.” said junior Sofia Gomez her opinion shows that the rivalry Between Chivas and Club America is not just about who Wins more games or  who has more Trophies. For some fans it is not just all about that, it is more about their history and tradition.Even though Club America has way more trophies than Chivas or has beaten Chivas more Doesn't mean every fan thinks that Club America is better. Chivas and Club America have way different histories and different ways they represent their own team which really makes the rivalry between them way more interesting than you think. Their fans have very different reasons why they support their favorite team and always want to see their favorite team be successful.This competition has continued for generations with fans passing it down their passion to their kids and family.Because of this the Rivalry became more than just a soccer game to each other fans it became something that brought people together and also give them something to argue about on who is the better,one who has the better players,who has the better coaches,they will always find something to argue about.

The conflict between the two teams started in 1959, when Club America’s coach, Fernando Marcos mocked Chivas after beating Chivas 2-0. Chivas players and fans did not like that at all; they took it very seriously after Fernando made that comment. Chivas waited for their next game to get revenge by beating Club America 2-0. Since that day, both teams have wanted to prove who is better . As years pass, their rivalry gets more and more intense, making every game they play important for each team 

Fans even fight with each other about who is the better team.

“Club America is better than chivas because they have more ligas wins then Chivas, and they beat FC Barcelona and Real Madrid,”  freshman Braulio Ruiz stated. 

However, there are Chivas fans  that have a very strong opinion, which is  that Chivas is better.

“I love Chivas so much, so even if they lose a game I will always support my favorite team,” said freshman Carly Flores. 

At  the end of the day, the rivalry between Club America and Chivas will always be a big part about Mexico's soccer teams and the passion that keeps their fans supporting their team no matter what happens, even if they lose to bad teams.

Comments


Sign Up for Email Updates

You have signed up for email notifications.

 ©2026 by Vashon Island High School. All rights reserved.
PIE_logo_withname_horiz 2026.png
bottom of page