Today's Screenwriters are Missing the Point

The movie Sense and Sensibility came out on October 16th, 2026, which has got me thinking about the amount of book-to-movie adaptations that have been released recently. Several adaptations have been released, from the various movies based on books by current authors like Colleen Hoover, to the tried and true classics being remade into movies. The viral sensation, Heated Rivalry, first released as a book in March, 2019. It’s since made its way to the screen 6 ½ years later, which skyrocketed the book series’s popularity. In a CBC article, they said that “Indigo (the print company with the rights to the series) reported that Reid’s book series has seen a 5,805 percent lift in sales since the TV adaptation premiered.” Heated Rivalry is a success story, but adaptations vary greatly in quality, and some are not successful. I want to go through some of my favorite book-to-movie adaptations and critique them on whether or not they successfully reflect their book.
Mean Girls is not a movie most people think of as an adaptation, but it is actually based on Queen Bees and Wannabes by Rosalind Wiseman. It’s a self-help book written for moms to help their daughters navigate through the social dynamics at school. Being a self-help book, there isn’t necessarily a story for the screenwriters to work off of. Instead, they created a storyline around the ideas expressed in the book. By doing this, audiences got a new, original story, and also attracted an audience who enjoyed the book or wanted to be educated.
One series that suffers from taking too many creative liberties is the Harry Potter movies. Don’t get me wrong, I love the books to death, but the movies leave something to be desired. It makes sense why they would make those books into movies. They are one of the best selling book series of all time, with 600 million copies sold worldwide as of 2023. The movies were also widely successful, but they are not accurate replications of the books themselves, since they gloss over entire subplots of the books and certain characters are missing entirely. Despite the movies being beautifully made, it broke my heart a bit that some of my favorite moments from the book never made the transition to screen. In Goblet of Fire for example, the other schools participating in the tournament felt fleshed out intentionally, whereas in the movie, the schools felt like they existed only to drive the plot.
I’m hoping that the HBO show is an improvement from the movies. Warner Brothers announced that a new television series based on the Harry Potter series would be released on December 25th, 2026. On the official Harry Potter website they reveal that the series will “add a degree of depth and detail we’ve never seen before, from magical moments to book-first details and brand new scenes.” It’s already been revealed to have characters in the show that don’t appear in the movies. For example, Peeves the Poltergeist will be included, which I’m hopeful will bring a more comedic atmosphere to the show. I think TV shows can go much more in depth than a movie can, simply because they have a longer runtime.
Wuthering Heights released earlier this year. The movie, starring Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie, was released to mixed reviews. There were people who, even before the movie’s release, were complaining about the casting of the leading man. They were mad that Elordi, a caucasian male, was playing the role of Heathcliff in the movie. It’s long been speculated that Emily Bronte wrote Heathcliff as a person of color. While it isn’t detrimental to the storyline; I think that by doing so, the director loses a major point of the book. Heathcliff being BIPOC brings a layer of depth and meaning to the book that is lacking in the movie. The movie highlights the issue with bringing books to the silver screen, which is that not everything can be included from a book, purely for the sake of screentime. I think that she could’ve created the same visuals, which were my favorite part of the movie, with a different actor and it still would’ve been successful.
To coincide with the last book in the series, creator Alice Oseman made the decision to not produce a final television season, but instead make a movie based on the last two Heartstopper books. While on paper this was a great idea, I think that this was such a missed opportunity. The final book was released two weeks before the movie, and naturally, I read it immediately. The book made me so happy, and I cried at the wholesome ending, so I was super excited to see this book on the big screen. However, the product was severely disappointing. Big sections of the book were missing from the movie. The movie also focused heavily on the relationship between its protagonists, while completely dismissing the side characters that made the book so special. So while it was advertised as a last goodbye, I only felt like I actually said farewell to Nick and Charlie.
I am under the firm belief that if movies are going to be ‘based off’ of a book, then they should do the book justice by following its source material closely, whether that be in a literal or symbolic way. It’s completely fine to change the plot, but then it’s an inspiration, not a recreation. Those that claim to be a recreation need to have writers that have a solid grasp on the content and meaning of the book, otherwise they do a disservice to the fans of the book. In a lot of ways, this connects to the overall trend occurring in Hollywood right now, where there are a lot of sequels and adaptations being made, as well as Hollywood not taking many artistic risks. I personally love the idea of sequels and prequels if they are done well. The problem nowadays is that it seems like sequels tend to feel like cash-grabs. This pattern of sequels and adaptations makes me feel like the movie industry is running out of steam creatively. I think we, the public, have allowed for this to happen by supporting movies that are cash-grabs. As mentioned, I love the idea of expanding the world of an already-created story, but if it’s done poorly, it just makes me frustrated. If people were to look at adaptations with a more critical lens, and stop supporting bad movies, then it might push the industry to make quality films again.

Comments