top of page

Trump’s Media Ban: A War Against Journalism

5 hours ago
4 min read
President Trump is questioned by CNN and Politico journalists outside Air Force One. Both of these news sources were not only banned from the White House, but also any aircraft carrying the president. Photo courtesy of Alex Kent.
President Trump is questioned by CNN and Politico journalists outside Air Force One. Both of these news sources were not only banned from the White House, but also any aircraft carrying the president. Photo courtesy of Alex Kent.

Freedom of the press took a historic blow on September 18th when President Trump removed CNN, Politico, and MS NOW’s access to the White House. He invalidated those reporters’ hard passes, the official credentials required to enter the grounds, leaving several journalists locked out and therefore unable to do their jobs as White House reporters. This has sparked nationwide outrage, with many arguing that the president’s policy violates Americans’ and reporters’ constitutional rights. 

President Trump’s post on Truth Social from September 18th explains his reasoning for the media ban.

"I am proud to announce that, effective immediately, I am banning Fake News CNN, MSNOW … and Politico … from the White House as a result of their constant 'reporting' FAKE NEWS!" he wrote. 

"Media outlets shouldn't be able to constantly write or report FICTION and LIES when they're covering the President of the United States, the Trump Administration, or the United States of America.” 

This statement is surprising, due to President Trump’s lack of evidence provided: he has yet to identify examples of false information released by the news companies in question. Moreover, while President Trump is firmly of the belief that many reporters from these banned news sources release fake news, there’s no legal precedent that permits his actions.

Shortly after President Trump attempted to block these reporters from entering the White House, all three of the restricted news outlets sued the administration. On September 24th, U.S. district judge Timothy Kelly blocked the media ban in an emergency 14-day order, finding it likely violated First Amendment and Fifth Amendment rights. On October 13-14th, Judge Kelly replaced this order with a longer-term preliminary injunction.

“The Court is skeptical—at least on this record—that Defendants’ interest in safeguarding national security is the actual motivation for, or is even advanced by, the revocation of Plaintiffs’ hard passes,” Kelly wrote in an eight-page ruling.

In short, Judge Kelly’s statement expresses that the media ban has not been justified by a standing lack of national security. In times of crisis and emergency, it is sometimes necessary  to limit journalist coverage to ensure the protection of the United States. Nevertheless, President Trump has voiced that the media ban’s purpose is not to protect national security, but to prevent the release of “fake news” and untruthful publications.

“Nothing in the record that predates this suit suggests that the revocation of Plaintiffs’ hard passes was motivated by national security concerns. Certainly, that is not what President Trump said when he announced that he was ‘banning’ Plaintiffs from the White House — instead, he focused on the alleged lack of truthfulness and negativity of Plaintiffs’ reporting,” Judge Kelly added.

On Vashon Island, peoples’ opinions are published in local newspapers, maintaining an informed community with access to a variety of opinions. This is made possible by dedicated Vashon reporters. 

“Access to public officials shouldn’t depend on whether they like our coverage,” remarked Aspen Anderson, editor of The Beachcomber.

The Beachcomber is a newspaper released weekly, providing an extensive database of current local and global news to the Vashon community. 

“Journalism matters to me because people deserve to understand the decisions that shape their lives,” stated Anderson. 

Decisions made in the White House shape the lives of millions. With this ban in place, the public will lack information on changes that directly impact their lives.

“[This administration] has asserted that the press somehow is just another ideologically driven propaganda source, ignoring the fact that journalists follow the ethics of professional journalism, that their entire reputation relies on the accuracy of their reporting,” said. Aaron Marsh, World History teacher at Vashon Island High School.

Credibility is a major source of success for press companies, which are often unsuccessful when providing unreliable information.

The White House press corps operates on a rotating TV pool system where networks take turns sending a crew to travel with the president and share footage with other outlets. While Judge Kelly blocked President Trump’s media ban and Politico, CNN, and MS NOW all have their hard passes returned, Trump Administration officials have halted all CNN (and some Politico) coverage and access aboard Air Force 1. Commonly referred to as “The Flying White House,” it is in crucial need of extensive news coverage where vastly influential decisions are made; however, the network is currently blocked from the Air Force 1 TV pool rotation altogether.

“On these occasions, the press has to stand together to defend our rights on behalf of the public,” commented Mark Thompson, editor-in-chief of CNN on October 14th. 

“This topic is one we’re never going to back down from. And no matter how many court cases, investigations, court appearances, and all the expense that that entails, we will fight this one to the end,” finished Thompson. 

For readers that find this event upsetting, you are not alone. There are numerous ways to stand up for your right to receive information and support journalists. 

“Start close to home. Subscribe to local news if you can, share reporting you’ve actually read, and speak up when officials make it harder for the public to get answers. Attend board meetings, ask questions and tell your representatives that press access matters to you. You can defend a news outlet’s right to report even when you dislike its coverage. And keep holding us accountable, too — a strong relationship between a newspaper and its readers includes room for criticism,” said Anderson.

Chairs of the many working press such as CNN journalists in the White House have been emptied. Since the media ban in September, there is an increasing lack of news coverage on goings on in the People’s House. Photo courtesy of Graeme Sloan.   
Chairs of the many working press such as CNN journalists in the White House have been emptied. Since the media ban in September, there is an increasing lack of news coverage on goings on in the People’s House. Photo courtesy of Graeme Sloan.   

Comments


Sign Up for Email Updates

You have signed up for email notifications.

 ©2026 by Vashon Island High School. All rights reserved.
PIE_logo_withname_horiz 2026.png
bottom of page